Run the same issue-sized task, inspect the diff, execute tests, count corrections, and verify pricing on the publication date.
What “best” means here
The best tool should finish a real issue with fewer bad edits, less babysitting, and a clean handoff. It does not win because its launch video looks expensive.
What still needs testing
Replace this section with verified hands-on findings for every listed product. Re-run the fixture when a major release changes the workflow.
Best for a desktop editor workflow
Cursor
Placement is temporary until verified testing is complete.
What works
- Add verified strength with evidence
What trips
- Add verified limitation with evidence
Best for a cloud, desktop, or terminal workflow
Codex
Placement is temporary until verified testing is complete.
What works
- Add verified strength with evidence
What trips
- Add verified limitation with evidence
Best for an alternative desktop coding workflow
Windsurf
Placement is temporary until verified testing is complete.
What works
- Add verified strength with evidence
What trips
- Add verified limitation with evidence